Pakistan’s Governance Challenge: Are Existing Structures Delivering Economic Value?
ICMA International report calls for stronger local institutions, fiscal devolution and administrative reforms to improve employment, investment and public services.

Governance Reform: ICMA calls for stronger institutions and better use of public resources.
Pakistan’s governance challenge is no longer just about maintaining administrative structures. It is increasingly about creating economic value from public resources, improving services and expanding employment opportunities.
Nearly 3.5 million people enter Pakistan’s labour force every year. Graduate unemployment has reached 18.3%, while more than 80% of provincial spending goes towards recurrent costs. Meanwhile, only one of the 47 projects in the federal public-private partnership (PPP) pipeline has reached the concession-agreement stage.
These figures raise questions about whether existing administrative arrangements can meet the country’s economic and development needs.
The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Pakistan (ICMA International) has examined these challenges in its research report, “ICMA’s Fiscal Vision for Pakistan: Aligning Administrative Structures with Economic Realities.” The report analyses how administrative structures affect fiscal capacity, employment, business activity, inflation and investment potential.
Employment demands a broader economic strategy
The report highlights significant unemployment among young graduates. Joblessness among graduates aged 20–24 stands at 32.8%. The rate rises to 42.3% among females.
Federal recruitment figures also show intense competition for government jobs. In 2024, 274,566 applicants competed for just 1,722 positions.
ECC Approves Export of 416,000 Tonnes of Sugar Despite IMF Deregulation Condition
These figures highlight the limits of relying on public-sector recruitment to absorb new entrants into the labour force. The report argues that Pakistan needs a broader strategy to create productive employment through private investment, entrepreneurship and regional economic development.
Rising administrative costs put development spending under pressure
The report also examines the pressure on public finances. More than 80% of provincial expenditure goes towards recurrent costs. Local governments accounted for less than 5% of total government expenditure in 2024.
This spending pattern raises concerns about the resources available for development. Further administrative expansion could add to costs without necessarily improving public services.
The report also cautions that bringing government offices closer to businesses and citizens does not automatically improve accessibility. Overlapping regulations, fragmented digital approvals and unclear responsibilities can create additional institutional layers.
Instead, effective governance requires integrated regulations, digital processes and clearly assigned responsibilities.
Weak project delivery limits infrastructure investment
Pakistan’s infrastructure investment pipeline presents another challenge.
The federal PPP pipeline lists 47 projects, including 22 qualified and 25 non-qualified projects. However, only one has reached the concession-agreement stage.
The report points to the need for stronger project preparation, financial and technical expertise, and coordination among different levels of government. These capabilities are essential to move projects from planning to implementation.
Report calls for stronger existing institutions
Drawing on administrative and fiscal experiences from seven countries, the report examines how governance systems can deliver better economic outcomes.
Its central recommendation is to strengthen institutional functions before creating additional administrative structures.
The proposed direction includes empowering existing divisional and district institutions, ensuring meaningful fiscal devolution to local governments and removing overlapping regulations.
It also calls for sharing specialised technical resources and controlling the costs of government establishments.
Measure reform through public outcomes
The report argues that administrative reform should focus on economic performance and public-service delivery rather than the number of administrative units.
Better employment opportunities, lower business compliance costs and improved investment facilitation should serve as key measures of progress.
Stronger local institutions and more productive use of public resources are equally important.
Ultimately, Pakistan’s governance reforms must demonstrate that administrative arrangements can deliver measurable economic value and improve citizens’ access to essential services.
