AI Song Sparks Criticism After Ahsan Iqbal Promotes Independence Day Tribute
The planning minister’s AI-generated song inspired by Allama Iqbal has drawn criticism from those who argue the government should support Pakistani artists instead of relying on artificial intelligence.
Ahsan Iqbal's AI-generated Independence Day song has sparked debate online.
AI Song shared by Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has triggered debate after he promoted an artificial intelligence-generated tribute to Pakistan’s youth on social media. The video, released by the Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives and URAAN Pakistan, draws inspiration from Allama Muhammad Iqbal’s philosophy of Khudi and the spirit of the Shaheen.
In a post on X, Ahsan Iqbal described the song as a message for young Pakistanis, saying the country’s future depends on a generation driven by confidence, knowledge, innovation and determination. He said Iqbal’s philosophy teaches that nations prosper when young people believe in their own potential and strive for excellence.
More than 100 words into the article – AI Song critics questioned the government’s decision to use artificial intelligence instead of hiring Pakistani musicians, composers and filmmakers. They argued that the country has no shortage of creative talent capable of producing an Independence Day anthem while also supporting the local arts and entertainment industry.
Critics Call for Support of Local Artists
The AI-generated music video has prompted criticism on social media, where many users said government-backed cultural projects should celebrate the work of Pakistani artists rather than rely on AI-generated visuals and music.
Critics contrasted the latest release with the government’s 2022 re-recorded national anthem, which featured musicians from across Pakistan and showcased the country’s cultural and regional diversity. Many described that project as a stronger example of promoting national talent.
Cotton Arrivals Jump 32% as Sindh’s Record Harvest Offsets Punjab Decline
Global Debate Over AI in Creative Industries
The controversy comes as artists around the world continue to raise concerns about artificial intelligence in creative fields.
American actor and filmmaker Seth Rogen has argued that people who immediately turn to AI for writing should reconsider pursuing creative professions. Filmmaker Christopher Nolan has also warned about the rapid expansion of AI, while more than 13,000 artists, including members of ABBA, Radiohead and actor Julianne Moore, have signed public statements calling for stronger protections against the unauthorised use of AI.
Supporters of artists argue that AI-generated music risks reducing original human creativity to disposable digital content while weakening opportunities for musicians, writers and filmmakers.
Pakistani Artists Raise Similar Concerns
The debate has also reached Pakistan’s entertainment industry. Actor Hira Tareen recently urged performers to examine contracts carefully after revealing that a production company asked her to surrender rights to her digital likeness.
She warned that production houses could gradually replace performers by training AI systems on existing footage, voices and performances, reducing the need for actors in future projects.
The latest controversy has reignited calls for public institutions to invest in Pakistan’s creative industries and commission original work from local artists. Critics argue that government-funded cultural campaigns should showcase human talent, particularly during national celebrations such as Independence Day.
